Latest Posts
5 minute read

How to Choose the Best Solution for Managing PTO and Employee Time Off

Person writing with black pen
Written by
Kate Vodopian

Managing paid time off (PTO) and employee leave is a critical task for businesses of all sizes. When it comes to finding the right tool, most companies have three options to consider: spreadsheets, a dedicated time-off tracker like TimeOff, or a comprehensive but expensive HR system. Each solution has its own advantages and drawbacks. Let’s explore these options below to help you decide which one fits your company’s needs.

‍

Option 1: Spreadsheets

‍

Spreadsheets are often the go-to solution for companies just starting out, thanks to their simplicity and low cost.

‍

Advantages:

  • Cost-effective: No software costs; easily accessible with tools like Excel or Google Sheets.
  • Flexible: Customizable to fit basic PTO tracking needs.
  • Familiar: Most employees already know how to use spreadsheets.

Disadvantages:

  • Error-prone: Manual entry can lead to mistakes like double bookings or incorrect leave balances.
  • Time-consuming: No automation means approvals, calculations, and reminders require manual effort.
  • Lack of visibility: Employees and managers may struggle to track overlapping leave dates or plan schedules efficiently.
  • Difficult to scale: As your team grows, managing PTO in a spreadsheet becomes chaotic and unwieldy.

Option 2: Expensive HR Systems

‍

Large, feature-rich HR systems offer an all-in-one approach to employee management, including PTO tracking.

‍

Advantages:

  • Comprehensive features: Covers not only time off but also payroll, performance reviews, and more.
  • Automated processes: Streamlines approvals, notifications, and leave calculations.
  • Scalable: Suitable for businesses with complex HR needs or large teams.

Disadvantages:

  • Cost-prohibitive: High upfront and ongoing expenses make this option impractical for small and mid-sized businesses.
  • Overly complex: Many features may go unused, especially for companies that don’t need full-scale HR management.
  • Setup challenges: Implementation and training require significant time and resources.

‍

Option 3: Dedicated Time-Off Tracker (e.g., TimeOff)

‍

A purpose-built time-off tracker like TimeOff offers a middle ground, combining efficiency with affordability.

‍

Advantages:

  • User-friendly: Simple to set up and easy to use for both employees and managers.
  • Automation: Automatically handles PTO requests, approvals, and notifications.
  • Transparency: Provides a shared calendar view, ensuring everyone can see who’s off and when.
  • Affordable: Costs less than a full HR system while delivering essential features.
  • Scalable: Grows with your business without becoming overly complex.

Disadvantages:

  • Limited scope: Focused solely on time-off management; does not include broader HR functionalities like payroll or recruitment.
  • Internet dependency: Cloud-based systems require a stable online connection.

Final Thoughts

‍

Spreadsheets may suffice for very small teams, and HR systems might work for large enterprises with complex needs, but for most businesses, a tool like TimeOff offers the ideal balance of affordability, simplicity, and functionality.

If your goal is to manage PTO efficiently without the hassle of spreadsheets or the expense of a full HR platform, a time-off tracker like TimeOff is a game-changer.

‍

‍

Kate Vodopian